Threads

Threads: A Case of the Emperor’s New Clothes

 

Tomorrow, Thursday, Meta is launching Threads, a new “text based conversation app” to rival Twitter.

The timing of the move, it has to be said, is perfect, with Twitter owner Elon Musk seemingly on a one man mission to destroy everything that was good about the service. The latest in a long line of damaging changes have seen the number of tweets an individual can read being restricted, popular user dashboard Tweetdeck being moved behind a paywall, and the continuing push to get users to sign up to the largely pointless Twitter Blue subscription service.

Threads is Mark Zuckerberg’s big play to bring another chunk of the social media environment into the Meta ecosystem to go alongside Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp. And much of the marketing communications internet seems to be very excited about it being the app that will sound the death knell for Twitter. Except me.

No Innovation

Threads is not a Twitter killer. And I’ll go as far as to say that after a hype-driven start, Threads will be one of the those Meta features that simply bubbles away in the background with no-one really paying it that much attention. It’ll die a long, slow death before it’s eventually phased out in a few years. Much as I hate what Musk has done with Twitter (and I REALLY hate what he’s done with it), Threads is not the answer. And here’s why.

Most, if not all of the talk around Threads isn’t about what an innovative new app it is which brings a genuine value to the world. Rather, it’s about how it’s ‘not Twitter’.

But is being ‘not Twitter’ enough to make it a success? Absolutely not. If that were the case, Mastodon or BlueSky would have killed Twitter already. Unless once it’s launched Threads brings something radically different to the world that Meta has accidentally forgotten to mention, it has no point of difference. The novelty of being ‘not Twitter’ will not attract users or, to be frank, last very long.

The Tale of Google+

“Ah yes,” you say, “but what about the fact that Meta will push Threads through Instagram to drive mass adoption?”

Sure, Instagram has a massive social graph, and prompting Instagram users to download the app is a surefire way of getting the ball rolling very fast. Expect updates in a few months time about how many tens or even hundreds of millions of people have installed the app.

But remember Google+? Google launched its last attempt at a social network to much fanfare in 2011, and by the end of that year 90 million people had signed up to it. In early 2012 Google attempted to use its user base on other products, notably Gmail, to further boost adoption. User numbers sky-rocketed. At the end of the day though, and despite being a better product than its competitor, Google+ was little more than ‘not Facebook’. As time progressed, interest waned and engagement within the platform died.

‘Not’ something isn’t ‘something’.

And none of this even considers Meta’s record on data privacy. Threads will not even be launched in the EU at the current time due to more stringent data privacy regulations in the rest of Europe. Should that not ring some alarm bells?! Or the fact that Meta doesn’t seem to give much of a crap about the impact of its platforms on mental health, society or the world at large. Quite simply, I just don’t trust that Mark Zuckerberg and Meta has the interests of anyone other than its shareholders at heart.

So if you’re asking me whether one social network run by a narcissistic sociopath will be any better than another social network run by a narcissistic sociopath, it’s going to take a hell of a lot to convince me.



WhatsApp chat